With cocktail names like Party Lobster, An Awfully Big Mustache, and Doug you’d expect the drinks at this colorful East Village hub to be, well, unexpected, and they certainly won’t let you down. Though the combinations—think: gin, scotch, smoked grapefruit, and popcorn butter—might sound like something from Willy Wonka’s happy hour, the shockingly delicious results and fun atmosphere will reward your adventurousness.
Nestled in the vibrant heart of New York City’s East Village at 105 First Avenue, Mister Paradise stands as a stylish cocktail bar that opened its doors in February 2019. Co-founded by industry veteran Will Wyatt, formerly of NoMad Hotel, and Eric Kruvant from the casual Drexler’s scene, it masterfully blends upscale mixology with an approachable, party-like energy that draws in locals and visitors alike. What sets it apart is its playful nod to pop culture, transforming the space into a nostalgic playground where every corner whispers references to beloved films and TV shows.
Step inside, and you’re immediately enveloped by the bar’s eclectic decor that pays homage to cinematic icons. The striking red room evokes the dystopian intensity of A Clockwork Orange, while the bathroom’s eerie blue-green hue mirrors the infamous Room 237 from The Shining, creating an immersive experience that delights film buffs and casual drinkers. Amidst this thematic whimsy, the atmosphere buzzes with gregarious lightheartedness—think dimly lit booths for intimate chats, a lively crowd mingling over inventive sips, and a soundtrack that keeps the energy high without overwhelming the senses. It’s the kind of spot where strangers become fast friends over shared laughs and unexpected discoveries.
At Mister Paradise, the cocktails steal the show with their bold, boundary-pushing profiles that fuse classic techniques with surprising twists. Signature drinks like the Party Lobster incorporate fermented habanero, garlic, and watermelon alongside tequila for a spicy-sweet punch that’s as memorable as it is refreshing, while others highlight buckwheat or tropical notes for a fresh take on familiar favorites. Recently revamped with a culinary-inspired menu, the offerings encourage experimentation—whether you’re a purist sticking to what you know or an adventurer letting the bartenders guide your palate. Paired with light bites and an open-door policy that feels welcoming rather than exclusive, it’s a testament to New York’s enduring spirit of reinvention, ensuring every visit feels like stumbling upon a hidden gem in the city’s endless nightlife tapestry.
Own or work here?